Showing posts with label photography. Show all posts
Showing posts with label photography. Show all posts

Thursday, May 5, 2011

Holy Trinity Church, 1956



This is such a great picture.

Woman painting Holy Trinity Catholic Church with watercolors on the trunk of her car.

March, 1956

Porter St, Corktown

(photo from the WSU Virtual Motor City Collection)

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Woodward Train Revisited

The Woodward Light Rail project is, by most accounts, actually going to happen. After an environmental impact study is complete, construction will begin on the first half of the line, which will extend from the river to West Grand Boulevard. The project is funded through a combination of public and private money, and Dave Bing is adamant that it's going to get done (literally, he said, "It's going to happen").

When people first hear that a light rail line is going to be built on Woodward, they are generally pretty skeptical. Detroit is promised a lot of things that never come to fruition, such as the constant succession of planned renovation projects for abandoned buildings. And, of course, it's easy to look at the People Mover and conclude that Detroit is not serious about mass transit. It would be great if we could build a world-class train system to carry passengers and spur development up and down Detroit's major avenues, but it can seem more like an urban planner's dream scenario than a potential reality for city at the brink of total collapse.

But I urge you not to be so pessimistic about mass transit in Detroit. The People Mover is far from the height of the city's transit planning. Detroit's streetcar system, which obviously included a Woodward line, operated nineteen routes at its peak in the middle of the twentieth century. So, remember that the proposed Woodward Avenue Light Rail would not be the first train to travel up and down the center of Woodward. If you need to see it with your own eyes, I will direct you to these two photographs, taken by Arthur Siegel in July, 1942:



Woodward looking south towards downtown from the Maccabees Building at Warren Ave. (Image from the Library of Congress)




Woodward looking north from the Maccabees Building. (Image from the Library of Congress)


On April 8, 1956, the Woodward line was the last piece of the system to be dismantled. The city's rail system was taken down in the 1950s as a result of the introduction of buses, which were considered more flexible and safer for riders, as they could be boarded from the curb as opposed to the middle of the street. Citizens of Detroit, however, mostly opposed the removal of the streetcars (Detroit Transit History).

We often hear that public transportation in Detroit was doomed by the city's obsession with automobiles. While this is true to some degree, keep in mind that Detroit's transit system was not always as embarrassing as you might think. The idea of a train traveling down Woodward or any of Detroit's avenues is not totally outrageous. Think of it this way: Detroit is not really building a train system, it's beginning to re-build it. And if you simply don't think cities need efficient mass transit or that it's a waste of money, I can only suggest that you join the rest of us in the twenty-first century.


Note: Arthur Siegel also took this photograph, which I posted earlier. These two are from the same collection of photos taken for the Farm Security Administration/Office of War Information.

Thursday, January 27, 2011

Rush Hour on Second Avenue, July 1942



Photograph taken by Arthur S. Siegel, a member of a team of photographers who documented American life from 1935 to 1944 for various government agencies, including the U.S. Farm Security Administration and Office of War Information. This photograph, like others in the FSA-OWI collection, is held by the Library of Congress. According to a biography written by the Chicago Museum of Contemporary Photograph, Arthur Siegel was born in Detroit and attended the University of Michigan and Wayne State University. He was a professor or photography at Wayne State and eventually at the Illinois Institute of Design in Chicago.

This photograph, taken from the Fisher Building facing south towards downtown, shows 5:30pm traffic on Second Avenue. The General Motors Building, now called Cadillac Place, can be seen on the left.

Friday, January 21, 2011

Last Days in Poletown

A couple weeks ago, I wrote about Poletown, a Polish community just east of downtown that was demolished in order to build the General Motors Detroit-Hamtramck Assembly Plant. I recently found that several sets of photographs were taken of Poletown as part of the Historic American Buildings Survey, a federal program intended to document America's architectural heritage. These two pictures show the Chene Street Commercial District, a section of Chene between I-94 and East Grand Boulevard which was completely erased from the grid for the sake of the plant's construction.



Corner of Chene and Milwaukee. (Image from the Library of Congress)



Chene between Trombley and Piquette. (Image from the Library of Congress)


These photographs were taken in 1981, right at the height of the controversy over the city's decision to displace the neighborhood's residents. The neighborhood appears to be on its last legs. Cars can still be seen in the street and parked along the curbs, but the buildings look dilapidated and the pictures give off a generally desolate feeling. Residents had begun taking relocation payments from the city and moving out of the neighborhood by this time, but the photographs may suggest that Poletown had emerged from the last couple decades in fairly rough shape, anyways. Documentation included in the Historic American Buildings Survey report hints at this, claiming that "the 1950s generally were very hard on the area" due to the steady movement of jobs and residents to the suburbs. The report goes on to say that "to the people of the area, the event which triggered the economic and social decline of the [Chene] Street Commercial District was the construction of the Ford Expressway (Interstate 94)." The report, from the Historic American Buildings Survey, can be found here.

Apparently, the construction of I-94 had cut Poletown into a north and a south section, which had done irreversible damage to the neighborhood by displacing some residents and breaking links between the remaining ones. This very closely resembles the way Corktown was split into two sections by the construction of I-75. It seems that by the time the neighborhood was scheduled for demolition in the 1980s, it was already on the decline.

On March 30, 1981, Time Magazine ran an article called "The Last Days of Poletown," which stated that 90% of Poletown residents had accepted relocation. The author writes that while a small group of protestors fight against the city, "other residents contend that the plant is actually a godsend, for it gives them the chance to leave the aging community and still get a decent price for their homes. Says John Kelmendi, 27, an area resident: 'Ninety percent of the socalled silent majority here want to go'" (Time Magazine, March 30, 1981).

So, these pictures may depict a neighborhood that has reluctantly accepted its fate after years of decline.