An article in Saturday's Free Press discusses some specific consequences of eliminating Michigan's tax credits for the redevelopment of brownfield sites and historic properties.
Gov. Snyder hopes to get rid of these tax credits (along with others), which have helped to finance the redevelopment of abandoned structures, to "create a more level playing field" for business in Michigan. Snyder is always saying that the future of Michigan is strongly tied to the future of Detroit, but he seems to ignore the fact that older cities like Detroit are at an automatic disadvantage when it comes to economic development. For most of these projects to work, an extra investment is needed.
The article lists five major projects which will almost certainly be scrapped if these tax credits are eliminated:
1. Shopping center at Old Redford High School
2. Retail/residential project at Uniroyal industrial site on Jefferson, next to the Belle Isle bridge
3. David Whitney Building
4. Gateway retail center at Woodward and 8 Mile
5. Several properties near Capitol Park
Showing posts with label redevelopment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label redevelopment. Show all posts
Monday, March 7, 2011
Friday, February 25, 2011
Cutting off brownfield and historic preservation tax incentives could halt development progress
Gov. Snyder's proposed state budget ruthlessly eliminates state tax incentives for a number of industries and projects in favor of lower overall business taxes. While the incentives for filmmaking have gotten the most attention, the elimination of state tax incentives for the redevelopment of brownfield sites and historic preservation may be the most crucial issue for Detroit.
The brownfield credits apply to "brownfield sites," which the Michigan Economic Development Corp. loosely defines as "properties that are either contaminated, blighted or functionally obsolete." These incentives, along with others for the preservation of historic properties, have been responsible for many high-profile redevelopment projects, including the Book-Cadillac and Fort Shelby. As I wrote earlier in a post about redevelopment around Grand Circus Park, the redevelopment of the Broderick Tower was literally made possible by state tax credits.
I understand the need for a balanced budget, but it seems that many of Snyder's proposals would set Detroit and Michigan backwards, leaving us to rely entirely on the hope that his "good climate for business" idea is going to pan out. Nancy Kaffer and Daniel Duggan of Crain's Detroit write that the elimination of these tax credits "could slow or stop the flow of redevelopment projects in Detroit," and the article quotes the vice president of board administration of the Detroit Economic Growth Corp., who says that "it's hard to think of a big project that hasn't used the credits."
With all the progress that's been made recently on these projects, the idea of cutting off the state tax incentives seems very misguided.
The brownfield credits apply to "brownfield sites," which the Michigan Economic Development Corp. loosely defines as "properties that are either contaminated, blighted or functionally obsolete." These incentives, along with others for the preservation of historic properties, have been responsible for many high-profile redevelopment projects, including the Book-Cadillac and Fort Shelby. As I wrote earlier in a post about redevelopment around Grand Circus Park, the redevelopment of the Broderick Tower was literally made possible by state tax credits.
I understand the need for a balanced budget, but it seems that many of Snyder's proposals would set Detroit and Michigan backwards, leaving us to rely entirely on the hope that his "good climate for business" idea is going to pan out. Nancy Kaffer and Daniel Duggan of Crain's Detroit write that the elimination of these tax credits "could slow or stop the flow of redevelopment projects in Detroit," and the article quotes the vice president of board administration of the Detroit Economic Growth Corp., who says that "it's hard to think of a big project that hasn't used the credits."
With all the progress that's been made recently on these projects, the idea of cutting off the state tax incentives seems very misguided.
Thursday, February 17, 2011
Grand Circus Park Revival
Grand Circus Park is experiencing a bit of a rebirth with news over the last couple months that three buildings on its south end are undergoing major redevelopment.

2007 photo of Grand Circus Park. The Broderick Tower is the taller building with the Verizon ad, which covers up the much more visually pleasing whale mural. To the immediate right is the David Whitney Building, and to its left is the Madison Building. Photo by Mike Russell, available under a Creative Commons license.
1. The Broderick Tower is being renovated by Motown Construction Partners and will have 127 apartments with a restaurant and lounge on the first few floors. Construction is expected to be done by September 2012. Although there have been attempts to rehab the Broderick in the past, this time the developers have more solid funding sources, including historic tax credits, according to Buildings of Detroit.
2. Across the street, the David Whitney Building is being purchased by a group of investors called the Whitney Partners on a loan from the Detroit Development Authority. There will be retail space on the first few floors along with some mixture of commercial and residential units. The building was constructed in 1915 and designed by Daniel Burnham, the architect/urban planner who did such minor things as creating the master plan for Chicago. According to the Free Press, "plans include restoring the Whitney's original classical architectural ornament that was stripped away a half-century ago." (Detroit Free Press)
3. The Madison Building was purchased by Quicken Loans, who will "rehab its upper floors into a hub for high-tech start-ups" (Model D Media). Quicken Loans has been pushing for development in Detroit for a while and moved its headquarters downtown last year.

2007 photo of Grand Circus Park. The Broderick Tower is the taller building with the Verizon ad, which covers up the much more visually pleasing whale mural. To the immediate right is the David Whitney Building, and to its left is the Madison Building. Photo by Mike Russell, available under a Creative Commons license.
1. The Broderick Tower is being renovated by Motown Construction Partners and will have 127 apartments with a restaurant and lounge on the first few floors. Construction is expected to be done by September 2012. Although there have been attempts to rehab the Broderick in the past, this time the developers have more solid funding sources, including historic tax credits, according to Buildings of Detroit.
2. Across the street, the David Whitney Building is being purchased by a group of investors called the Whitney Partners on a loan from the Detroit Development Authority. There will be retail space on the first few floors along with some mixture of commercial and residential units. The building was constructed in 1915 and designed by Daniel Burnham, the architect/urban planner who did such minor things as creating the master plan for Chicago. According to the Free Press, "plans include restoring the Whitney's original classical architectural ornament that was stripped away a half-century ago." (Detroit Free Press)
3. The Madison Building was purchased by Quicken Loans, who will "rehab its upper floors into a hub for high-tech start-ups" (Model D Media). Quicken Loans has been pushing for development in Detroit for a while and moved its headquarters downtown last year.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)